Why is a Lisbon soccer team trying to unmask Portuguese bloggers in US court?

Enlarge / Pizzi of SL Benfica in action during the Liga NOS match between SL Benfica and FC Porto at Estadio da Luz on October 7, 2018 in Lisbon, Portugal.Gualter Fatia/Getty Images

In April 2018, a professional Portuguese soccer team sued three major American tech companies–Google, Cloudflare, and Automattic–in federal court in Los Angeles. The soccer club, Benfica, alleged that the American companies were partially responsible for disseminating internal memos, presentations, and emails obtained via a 2017 phishing attack against it. However, in recent weeks, American lawyers for Benfica agreed to remove the tech firms from the lawsuit, most of whom had formally filed motions to dismiss previously.

Strangely, the club’s attorneys have also recently asked the court to “order the disabling” of two anonymous blogs that have continued to disseminate the material, despite the fact that multiple Portuguese media outlets have also published some of the same documents as well. But while Google has been removed as a defendant, last month the company formally notified two Portuguese soccer bloggers that it may give their subscriber information to Benfica as part of the lawsuit. The blogs–Artista Do Dia and Mister Do Cafe–use Blogspot, a website owned by Google.

Those bloggers can try to “quash” the subpoena by having a California attorney appear on their behalf, a move that could be quite expensive. “To respond to this summons [we] would have to pay tens of thousands of dollars and that answer would not guarantee anything,” wrote Mister Do Cafe in a Portuguese-language post from Thursday. “The court could even give me reason, but that would not prevent Benfica from returning to the case with other subpoenas. This disproportion of means between a simple blog and a billing company is an impediment to any kind of justice in the American judicial system.

It is what I call the justice of money.”

Come out, come out wherever you are

The lawsuit, Sport Lisboa e Benfica v. John Doe et al, primarily names an unknown person (or persons) who were responsible for the attack and alleges violations of numerous American laws, including the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act and the Stored Communications Act, among others. For now, the lawsuit has provided no evidence that the alleged “hacker” is even in the United States, much less in the Los Angeles area, where the case was filed.

It is unclear why this lawsuit has been brought in an American federal court at all, particularly given that, as Google itself noted in an earlier filing, the actual phishing attack took place in Portugal. These documents obtained through the phishing attack contained explosive purported revelations, according to The New York Times, which reported on the case on Wednesday:

It included a Benfica slide show detailing an apparent effort to gain greater influence over federation and league officials, as well as details of how the club spent a large sum of money on a witch doctor from Guinea-Bissau to boost the team’s performances. There were also documents suggesting connections between the club and the men responsible for overseeing refereeing in Portugal.

Finally, by late last year, the Benfica documents began appearing on an anonymous Portuguese-language blog, called O Mercado do Benfica (“The Benfica Market”).

Attorneys for Benfica have also gone after Regtime Ltd. and Realistic Group LLC (who operates http://rgho.st/), two Russian companies that temporarily hosted some of the files online. But legally serving entities in Russia is nearly always a futile effort, as for 15 years, Russia has refused to comply with the international treaty known as the Hague Convention that describes rules for serving defendants in foreign countries. The soccer club has also named a Canadian company, FranTech Solutions, as a defendant and is currently undergoing the procedure to legally serve them as well.

Christopher Gonzalez, one of Benfica’s lawyers, based in Pasadena, California, did not respond to Ars’ request for comment.

The Beautiful Game - Celtic: Lisbon LionsAn ideal gift for all Celtic fans, this infographic print documents Celtic's march to a historic triumph, becoming the first British team to win the European Cup in 1967. The team have become known as the 'Lisbon Lions'.Designed to look classy and stylish and will suit all rooms in the home. - More Info

Évora Wine Tour – Full Day  + City Sightseeing Lisbon Hop-on Hop-offHighlights Visit and Wine Tasting at the Herdade do Esporão Cellar - Romanesque Gothic Cathedral, University, Bones Chapel, Évora’s Roman Temple Explore and absorb all the major classic sights of Lisbon Enjoy a guided walking tour in Évora, a UNESCO Site since 1986 See landmarks like the Roman Temple, the Romanesque Gothic cathedral and the Bones Chapel Mosteiro dos Jerónimos, Castelo de São Jorge and Museu Nacional de Arte Antiga are essential must-sees for anyone visiting Lisbon Ticket Includes Bus ticket  Évora Wine Tour – Full Day ticket Ticket Excludes Hotel Pick Up Food and Drinks    **Please Note: If below 13 years old you will need to purchase separate tickets for Bus Tour and Évora Wine Tour.** * April to October - More Info

Personalised Celtic in Europe Football Team History BookTop stories include being the first British team to lift the European Cup with that glorious win over Inter Milan in 1967 to secure the European Cup. Other early coverage includes the 1970 Cup Final against Feyenoord, and the heart-breaking 1972 semi-final against old rivals Inter Milan where the team lost on penalties. Relive the exciting 2-0 win over Real Madrid in 1980, the 5-0 slaughter of Sporting Lisbon in 1983 and the nail biting UEFA Cup Final vs FC Porto in 2003. Also covered are Champions League encounters such as the 4-3 win over Juventus in 2001, the 3-1 defeat of Anderlecht in 2003 and beating Man Utd 1-0 in 2006. - More Info - EAN: 9781782716112

Personalised Celtic in Europe Football Team History BookTop stories include being the first British team to lift the European Cup with that glorious win over Inter Milan in 1967 to secure the European Cup. Other early coverage includes the 1970 Cup Final against Feyenoord, and the heart-breaking 1972 semi-final against old rivals Inter Milan where the team lost on penalties. Relive the exciting 2-0 win over Real Madrid in 1980, the 5-0 slaughter of Sporting Lisbon in 1983 and the nail biting UEFA Cup Final vs FC Porto in 2003. Also covered are Champions League encounters such as the 4-3 win over Juventus in 2001, the 3-1 defeat of Anderlecht in 2003 and beating Man Utd 1-0 in 2006. - More Info - EAN: 9781782716112

Pro Evolution Soccer Management Used PS2 GameIt's almost as if Konami hadn't already given us enough of its wonderful Pro Evolution Soccer (PES) games...here comes the management version. In a relationship that's already heading towards the rocks? Watch out for the Pro Evolution Soccer Management iceberg! Yup, Konami has gone all 'in-depth' on us and taken PES to its logical conclusion. All the effort that you put into achieving varying degrees of success with PES4 and /or PES5 hasn't gone to waste, you'll be glad to know, as your team data can be imported to the management sim. However, if you're starting from scratch, you have 116 teams from six European leagues to choose to manage - real players and licensed leagues including the Eriedivisie, Serie A and La Liga. Pro Evolution Soccer Management invites wannabe managers to experience the highs and lows of a career in football's toughest job. Every aspect of your chosen team's training, preparation and performance has to be taken into account. You can get some assistance with scouting and specialist training by appointing coaching staff to fit your requirements. Remember that behind every manager, there's a strong backroom. But when your team goes over the white line, unless they perform, and follow the instructions and training you have given to them, well...you'll get the boot before any of the players do. Welcome to the relationship-breaker that is football management. Football on the PS2 doesn't get any better than Pro Evolution Soccer. This is the perfect accompaniment.. With free UK delivery and covered by our quality guarantee, saving you money on your DVDs. Delivered within 5-7 working days. - More Info

You may also like...

       
Apps & Games Clothing Electronics & Photo Large Appliances
Baby Womens Apparel Garden Lighting
Beauty Mens Apparel Outdoors Luggage
Books Girls Apparel Health & Personal Care Pet Supplies
Car Boys Apparel Home Shoes & Bags
Motorbike Computers & Accessories Kitchen Equipment Sports & Outdoors
Fashion DIY & Tools Jewellery Toys & Games