Which iMac Should I buy: 21.5in vs 27in

Apple sells six different iMacs in two different sizes. The size is the most obvious difference – either you choose a model with a 21.5in or a 27in display (measured diagonally). But there are other variations that mean that finding the iMac that suits you best might not be as obvious as you would expect – which is probably why you are here reading this article.

We also have the following Mac Buying Advice that might be useful to you:

Should I buy the cheapest iMac?

A good place to start is budget. Just how much iMac can you get for your money? As the price increases the specs of the models improve, of course.

If you have around GBP1,000 to spend you might think that the base model, which starts at GBP1,049 / £1,099 is the one to buy. There are a few reasons why we would dissuade you from doing so, though.

First of all it doesn’t have the 21.5in 4K screen that the other 21.5in iMacs offer. The screen on the entry-level iMac is LED-backlit, shows ‘millions of colours’ and is capable of 1920×1080 resolution.

The other Retina 4K displays offer 4096×2304 resolution, are brighter, and support 1 billion colours. This means there will be more detail visible in everything, especially photos and movies. The entry-level model also only has a dual-core 2.3GHz processor, with all the other iMacs offering 3GHz or more quad-core processors.

That’s quite a difference as soon as you do something that needs power. There is no Fusion Drive as standard on this model – all you get is an old-school hard drive that will slow things down, you could upgrade this to a Fusion Drive for GBP90, which combines some flash storage and speeds things up. Read about why you should get a Fusion Drive with your iMac.

The other thing letting this iMac down is the fact that it is the only one with an integrated graphics card – Intel’s Iris Plus Graphics 640, which is incorporated onto the processor.

All the other iMacs have superior, discreet graphics cards from AMD which are better suited to games and other graphic intensive operations. We would tend to recommend that when you buy a new Mac you always do so with the future in mind. You want to buy a Mac that will last you a few years because Macs are notoriously difficult to upgrade so generally we say get the most RAM and the fastest processor you can for your money.

Because you can’t upgrade it later. So in the case of the entry level Mac, you could pay GBP180 for 16GB RAM, GBP90 for a Fusion drive (or a 256GB SSD which would be even better, as long as you don’t mind sacrificing some storage capacity). All that brings the price to GBP1,319.

Your other option to consider if you really are limited to a grand is to look at Apple’s refurbished store.

Here there are previous generation iMacs with faster quad-core processors (although a generation earlier these will still perform better than the current model’s slower dual-core processor). Read about the refurbished store here: How to buy a cheap Mac from the Apple Refurbished Store. Want the entry-level iMac?

You can buy it from Apple here.

Should I buy the GBP1,249 / £1,299 21.5in iMac?

The next iMac in the range is GBP150 more, but offers, in our option, far more than GBP150 worth of extras compared to the entry-level iMac. You get that 4K display, a quad-core processor and a Radeon Pro graphics card. This model does still lack some features that you might find useful though.

It offers a standard hard drive rather than the Fusion Drive offered by the next iMac in the range. However, you can to upgrade this model to have a Fusion Drive for GBP90, bringing the price to GBP1,339. Given that the next model in the series costs GBP1,449 would this actually be a good idea?

We’ll investigate in the next section.

There’s another build-to-order option to consider here. You could configure to a 3.6GHz i7 processor for an extra GBP270. When we tested the i7 processors that come as standard on the MacBook Pro we were impressed at how much better they were when compared to the i5 processor in the iMac so we strongly recommend that you consider this upgrade if you’re going to do more intensive tasks.

If you were to add the GBP270 processor, and the GBP90 Fusion Drive, your 21in iMac would cost you GBP1,609 though, and that pushes you way over the price of the next iMac in the range.

Want the mid-range 21in iMac? You can buy it from Apple here.

Should I buy the GBP1,449 / £1,499 21.5in iMac?

The top of the range 21.5in iMac costs GBP200 more that the mid range model, but as we just explained, you could choose the Fusion Drive as a build to order option for another GBP90. If you were going to do that should you consider paying another GBP110 to go the whole hog?

What else does the top-of-the range 21.5in iMac offer that the mid-range model doesn’t? It all comes down to processors and graphics cards. Where the mid-range iMac features a 3GHz quad-core processor, with the top-of-the range model you get 3.4GHz.

And rather than a Radeon Pro 555 you get a Radeon Pro 560. Because we haven’t tested both of these machines we cannot tell you how much faster the more expensive machine will be, but it will be faster. The question is does it really matter?

Whether the processor and graphics card matter depends a lot on what you will be doing with your iMac.

If it’s going to be used primarily for emails, web browsing, writing documents in Word and spreadsheets in Excel you could probably reduce your budget to the GBP1,000 level above. But if you are likely to spend some time working with images and video, watching movies and other media, and playing a few games, the processor and the discreet graphics cards will make a difference to you. Is the difference between the GBP1,249 and GBP1,449 iMacs going to make a difference to you?

We don’t think so. If on the other hand you are going to be playing graphic intensive games, or editing a lot of video or photography, then there is an argument for paying the extra GBP200 (or GBP110 if you have already decided to get the Fusion Drive for the extra GBP90).

So, you’ve decided that you need the 3.4GHz GBP1,449 iMac? Nothing is ever that simple.

For another GBP300 you could get an almost identical 3.4GHz machine with a 27in 5K display. But before we look at that option, there is one more option to consider. The build-to-order 3.6GHz i7 processor that you could get with this machine for an extra GBP180, bringing the price to GBP1,629.

Remember that combination of processor and the Fusion Drive for the mid-range 21.5in iMac cost GBP1,609. We’re talking GBP20 difference here for the slight tweek in the graphics card. You might as well spend it.

Want the top-of-the-range 21in iMac?

You can buy it from Apple here.

Should I buy the GBP1,749 / £1,799 27in iMac

With an identical 3.4GHz processor but costing GBP300 more than the top-of-the-range 21.5in iMac, GBP1,749 model might sound like a high price to pay for this entry level 27in iMac, but when you consider that 5K displays aren’t cheap, the GBP300 might pale into insignificance. The question is do you really need a bigger screen, or could a 21in do the job for you just as well?

If you need a 5K display then obviously it goes without saying that you need to be looking at the 27in range of iMacs. If you were to shop around outside of the Apple offering could you get as good a 5K display as the one on the iMac, maybe, but it would very likely cost you more.

The computer that most often gets compared to the 27in iMac is the 28in Microsoft Surface Studio. Where the iMac boasts a resolution of 5,120 x 2,880, the Surface Studio offers 4,500 x 3,000.

The biggest thing in the Surface Studio’s favour is the fact that you can lay it flat and use it like a graphics tablet. We compare the two models here: iMac 5K (2017) vs Microsoft Surface Studio.

This comes at a price though, the Surface Studio is more expensive than the top-end iMac, starting at GBP2,999 / £2,999. Going back to the question of whether you need the 27in display, if you don’t need all the pixels but you do need more surface area there are other options. You can plug a second screen into the 4K iMac display and use two displays.

If you frequently have a lot of windows open this may be a better set up for you than trying to spread everything across a 27in display.

If you were to buy a second screen to use with the 21in iMac you could probably spend less than GBP300. If you don’t need a 5K display then that’s what we’d recommend. But if you need a 5K display then Apple’s 27in iMac is the best you can get.

Want the entry-level 27in iMac? You can buy it from Apple here.

Should I buy the GBP1,949 / £1,999 27in iMac

Assuming that you do need that 5K display, should you spend another GBP200 to get the next model up? At almost GBP2,000 the mid-range 27in iMac comes with a 3.5GHz processor (rather than the 3.4GHz processor of the model below) and a Radeon Pro 575 graphics card (rather than the 570).

Is that slight processor and graphics tweak really worth another GBP200?

We’re not sure it is. As before we haven’t run tests on these two Macs, so we can’t say exactly how much faster the mid-range model will be, but we don’t think it will be GBP200 quicker. In may ways we think this mid-range model serves only as a stepping stone between the entry-level 27in iMac and the top-of-the-range 27in iMac.

If it wasn’t there then the huge GBP500 leap to GBP2,249 / GBP2,299 would seem astronomical. The only reason to consider this model is the fact that it is configurable up to 64GB RAM, while the model below can only be configured up to 32GB.

Of course if you were to add the 64GB RAM you’d be paying another GBP1,260, taking the price to GBP3,209. If you need 64GB RAM then this might be a better option for you than adding it to the next model up, which would bring that price up to GBP3,509.

Really, 32GB is enough for the vast majority of users. Another build-to-order option is the 4.2GHz i7 processor, which as we discussed above is a better option than the standard i5 processor and potentially worth the extra GBP270. In fact, it’s definitely worth upgrading to this processor if you are thinking about buying the top of the range iMac because even with this processor added this model is still less expensive than the one above it at GBP2,219.

Want the mid-range 27in iMac? You can buy it from Apple here.

Should I buy the GBP2,249 / £2,299 27in iMac?

The top of the range 27in iMac offers a 3.8GHz processor, which is a decent leap from 3.5GHz. It also offers twice as much storage – a 2TB Fusion Drive.

The graphics card is better too. Is all that worth the extra GBP300 compared to the mid-range model? Obviously if you need the fastest processor and the best graphics you can get then this is the iMac to choose.

As we said early on in this article, we always recommend spending as much as your budget will allow to future proof your Mac because it’s not easy to upgrade it at a later date. With that in mind, should you choose the best build to order options when you buy this model?

You could add a 4.2GHz quad-core i7 processor for another GBP180 – the i7 part of that is almost as significant at the 4.2GHz because all the standard iMacs offer i5 processors. We’d recommend updating to the 4.2GHz processor for power users.

However, this option is also available on the GBP1,949 iMac. If you add the 4.2GHz processor to each model you have one at GBP2,429 and one at GBP2,219. Given that the only difference between the two models then is the bigger storage and the faster graphics card of the more expensive model, we’d be inclined to save some money and opt for the GBP2,219 model.

Want the top-of-the-range 27in iMac?

You can buy it from Apple here.

Find out which is best, MacBook Pro, iMac, iMac Pro, or Mac Pro.

Plus read all about the history of the iMac.

You may also like...

Apps & Games Clothing Electronics & Photo Large Appliances
Baby Womens Apparel Garden Lighting
Beauty Mens Apparel Outdoors Luggage
Books Girls Apparel Health & Personal Care Pet Supplies
Car Boys Apparel Home Shoes & Bags
Motorbike Computers & Accessories Kitchen Equipment Sports & Outdoors
Fashion DIY & Tools Jewellery Toys & Games