Hashtag Activism, book review: A sign of the times

hashtag-activism-main.jpg

Hashtag Activism: Networks of Race and Gender Justice • by Sarah J. Jackson, Moya Bailey, and Brooke Foucault Welles • MIT Press • 296 pages • ISBN: 978-0-262-04337-3 • $19.95 / £15.99

Last year, an inveterate internet observer called 2010 “peak cyber utopia”. That was the year Western social media users basked smugly in the belief that their technology had liberated numerous Arab countries from oppressive governments. Since then, we’ve learned that social media was only one of many tools, not a cause, watched Western democracies undermine their own democratic institutions, and come to realise that actually the internet can’t do everything.

And yet. It’s one of the peculiarities of Twitter (in particular) and other social media that new movements can take shape in full public view while entirely escaping the notice of those whose bubbles don’t intersect them. In Hashtag Activism, Sarah J. Jackson, an associate professor at the University of Pennsylvania’s Annenberg School, feminist scholar and ‘misogynoir’ coiner Moya Bailey, and Northeastern University associate professor Brooke Foucault Welles, tell the stories of a number of these movements, beginning in 2009.

Theirs is a rare approach these days; these are the first authors in a long time who aren’t focusing on platform abuse. Their index has no entries for trolls, abuse, or bots.  

On Twitter, hashtags — literally, the # sign in front of a word — were the brainchild of user Occupy and much more since. Although the authors primarily talk about Twitter, they acknowledge that other social media — chiefly Facebook — are equally important.

Access all areas

They begin by observing that social media affords racial minorities, women, transgender people, and “others aligned with justice and feminist causes” new access that was not available via traditional media. They then go into detail in six chapters featuring the following hashtags: #YesAllWomen, #MeToo, #FastTailedGirls, #YouOKSis, #SayHerName, #GirlsLikeUs, #OscarGrant, #TrayvonMartin, #Ferguson, #FalconHeights, #AllMenCan, and #WhiteWhileCriming. 

At least some of these ought to be familiar to anyone who follows the news in mainstream media. Others may be unfamiliar, particularly to a British audience. I had not, for example, encountered #FastTailedGirls or #YouOKSis, which were used to build knowledge of black feminism. Nor had I seen #GirlsLikeUs, which the authors use as an example of community building and advocacy, in this case for transgender women. 

Finally, #AllMenCan and #WhiteWhileCriming examine the way offers of allyship can turn into appropriation. In their example, what began as white men offering to join in opposing discriminatory policing by providing examples of times when they were let off lightly for infractions for which their non-white counterparts would have been more severely punished, turned into a performance of privilege. 

The authors do not suggest that online organising is enough by itself to effect real social change. But, they conclude, online matters. “Peak cyber utopia” may have to wait.

RECENT AND RELATED CONTENT

Social media is the most popular method of engaging with brands

Australia warned to not ignore domestic misinformation in social media crackdown

Most of us avoid posting on social media because of co-workers

Social media during protests: The good, the bad, and what must change

Analysis: Trump order could turn social media platforms into publishers

Read more book reviews


Gary William Friedman: The Me Nobody Knows: Piano  Vocal  Guitar: Mixed Songbook Gary William Friedman: The Me Nobody Knows: Piano Vocal Guitar: Mixed Songbook
9 vocal selections from the 1970 Obie Award winner for Best Musical including: Black · Dream Babies · How I Feel · If I Had a Million · Let Me Come In · Light Sings · Sounds · This World · The Tree. Also includes copy of the original New York Times review. 9 vocal selections from the 1970 Obie Award winner for Best Musical including: Black · Dream Babies · How I Feel · If I Had a Million · Let Me Come In · Light Sings · Sounds · This World · The Tree. Also includes copy of the original New York Times review.
£13.99
by: Hal Leonard

Shadings for Orchestra: Orchestra: Score Shadings for Orchestra: Orchestra: Score
Shadings was commissioned for The American Composers Orchestra UnSafe series and premiered at Zankel-Carnegie Hall._x001A_In Laura Schwendinger's Shadings richly scored shimmering music ebbed and swirled in tandem with a series of enigmatic photographs projected above the orchestra. The photographs were taken in Japan by the composer's cousin Leni Schwendinger who also designed evocative lighting to complement the images._x001A_- Review by Vivian Schweitzer in The New York Times
£99.00
by: Lauren Keiser Music Publishing

Oliver Knussen: Cantata: Oboe: Instrumental Work Oliver Knussen: Cantata: Oboe: Instrumental Work
In his Financial Times review Max Loppert says '. . .the title aptly reflects both the songful character of the musical invention and the relationship of wind solo to string trio. . .a composition of great charm and precise character; its other virtues of well-found proportions distinctive harmonic movement and secure control of incident must not be allowed to sound negative ones.'

9th March 1981
£7.99
by: Faber Music


Franz Wilhelm Abt: The Flowers' Review: SATB: Vocal Score Franz Wilhelm Abt: The Flowers' Review: SATB: Vocal Score
The Flowers' Review
£2.25
by: Novello and Co